top of page

Creature 
Fast Facts

Introducing you to extinct species.

BLUE PIKE

THE BLUE PIKE/

BLUE WALLEYE

1. The blue pike, Sander vitreus glaucus, also called the blue walleye is an extinct color morph of the yellow walleye. 2. The blue pike was labeled a unique subspecies of the yellow walleye in 1926, but genetic testing showed that it was not a unique subspecies. 3. The U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service declared the blue pike as endangered in 1967 and extinct in 1983, even though it was not deemed a unique species genetically. 4. The blue coloration may have helped it blend into the deeper waters of the GReat Lakes, while the yellow variant would help the walleye blend into shallower, brighter water. 5. The blue pike’s eyes were larger and placed higher than the yellow walleye variation, although the reason is unknown. 6. The blue walleye only grew to 12 - 18 inches in length and weighed just 3 pounds on average, but records show some reach almost 8 pounds. The yellow walleye variation commonly grows to be 10 pounds, with a record of 18 pounds in 1933. 7. The blue pike population drastically declined from 20 million pounds of fish caught in 1955 to only 79,000 pounds in 1959. By 1964 only 200 pounds of blue pike were caught. 8. The blue pike was a common commercial fish in Lake Erie and Lake Ontario in the Great Lakes region. 9. Efforts were made, too late, to save the blue pike from extinction. There are rumors that blue pike fingerlings were placed into other, smaller lakes by hatcheries at the time, but no one has been able to confirm that. 10. Some yellow walleye caught today, especially those caught in Northern Canada, do have a blue, turquoise color thought to be caused by the sandercyanin protein in the fish’s mucus. This blue sheen on these walleye can be wiped off since it’s completely external, unlike the historic blue pike’s permanent coloration. 11. Ohio angler Jim Anthony, claimed to have caught a blue pike in 1962 and preserved it in his freezer for 37 years in hopes that his fish could help bring back the species. That specimen was tested and actually showed no distinct genetic difference between the blue pike and yellow walleye. 12. In the original version of The Lorax, by Dr. Seuss said, “They will walk on their fins and get woefully weary in search of some water that isn’t so smeary. I hear things are just as bad up in Lake Erie.” This described how bad the blue pike’s habitat was at that time. 13. In 1969 a South Dakota fishery secretly stocked 525 blue pike fingerlings in an effort to save the species from extinction. The exact location of these efforts has never been discovered.

Extinction 
Cometh

Facing the light at the end of the tunnel

EXTINCTION DATE

1983

The blue pike was once an abundant fish of the Great Lakes. It was a commonly caught commercial fish in the region and a common item on local menus. Although genetic testing on specimens of preserved “blue pike” have shown that it was not a unique subspecies, but a morph of the yellow walleye, the blue pike did look and behave differently. Its blue coloration, smaller size, larger eyes, and higher eye placement seemed to benefit those walleye living in deeper water, while the yellow phase benefited those living in shallower, brighter water. Several factors affected the populations of many fish in the Great Lakes in the mid-1900’s. Three other species went extinct around this same time period in the region. Over a billion pounds of blue pike were caught between 1885 and 1962. Carol Stepien, the same scientist who concluded that the blue pike and yellow walleye were genetically identical, published a paper about the decline of the blue pike. Stepien’s research pointed to three main reasons for the population collapse. The first, she stated was, “massive habitat loss during the 20th century including industrial waste, draining of wetlands, shoreline armoring, channelization of waterways and intense dredging operations around Lake Erie.” Secondly, “high levels of phosphorous in the 1960s, near the end of the blue pikes’ existence in the lake, as causing large algae blooms and oxygen depletion.” The final nail in the coffin for the blue pike, according to Stepien was, ““Most walleye return to spawning grounds and interbreed with their own group. When you overfish, this may break down the reproductive structure and lead to interbreedings.” One added factor might have been the invasive sea lamprey which latches onto native fish and drains them slowly of their body fluids. Lampreys have been an invasive problem since they were first detected in the Great Lakes in Lake Ontario in the late 1800’s and in Lake Erie in 1921. The blue pike population drastically declined from 20 million pounds of fish caught in 1955 to only 79,000 pounds in 1959. By 1964 only 200 pounds of blue pike were caught. The last confirmed blue pike caught in Canada was in 1965. The blue pike was listed as endangered in 1967 and declared extinct in 1983. Although Jurassic Park is fiction, scientists are working on several de-extinction projects. In fact, in 2003 scientists did bring back the extinct Pyrenean ibex, a type of wild goat, for 7 minutes before it died, showing de-extinction is possible. The blue pike is an interesting case, since genetically it was the same as the yellow walleye. The gene for the steel blue color, smaller size, and larger eye size could be unlocked by scientists and emphasized in the current yellow walleye population. There is also the possibility of finding the fabled lake where a South Dakota fishery secretly stocked 525 fingerlings blue pike fingerlings in 1969 in an effort to save the species from extinction. The Great Lakes region is the focus on conservation efforts by the United States and Canada. The Great Lakes Restoration Initiative in the United States is currently focusing on “five major focus areas to serve as a guide for collaborative restoration work. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is a proud federal partner in the implementation of the GLRI, and manages projects in the following focus areas; toxic substances and areas of concern, invasive species (there are 180 invasive species currently identified), nonpoint source pollution impacts on nearshore health, habitats and species, and foundations for future restoration actions.” The fact that these efforts have helped the yellow walleye rebound to “thriving numbers” once again, show promise for the blue pike and other fish species that call the Great Lakes home. If the blue pike was brought to life, could it ever be reintroduced to its native homeland in Lake Ontario and Lake Erie?

Lazarus
Tales

Short stories of return

COMING SOON

The blue pike's Lazarus tale has yet to be written, but what adventures will await it when it returns to the Great Lakes? Stay tuned to find out.

More to Explore
All answers lead to more questions

An image of a blue pike
Image from Great Lakes Now

Although the blue color is faded, this is a specimen of blue pike
Image from Great Lakes Now

 A blue pike specimen
Image from Outdoor News

 A blue pike specimen image by the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation
Image from Nature Conservancy of Canada

An old advertisement for Lake Erie blue
Image from Great Lakes Now

Blue pike were a common item in restaurants near the Great Lakes
Image from Nature Conservancy Canada

 The deep water cisco, longjaw cisco, and shortnose cisco also went extinct in the Great Lakes in the 1960's - 1980's
Image from United States Department of the Interior

 This report from 1970 shows the total fish production of the blue pike until its extinction
Image from United States Department of the Interior

A blue morph - yellow walleye caught in 2013 shows that the yellow walleye can come in a blue coloration
Image from Wikipedia

A yellow walleye caught in the Great Lakes
Image from Great Lakes Angler

The deepwater cisco, Coregonus johannae, went extinct in the 1960's
Image from Ontario Freshwater Fishes Life History Database

The longjaw cisco, Coregonus alpenae, went extinct in  1983
Image from Ontario Freshwater Fishes Life History Database

The Shortnose cisco, Coregonus reighardi, has not been seen since 1985
Image from Ontario Ministry of the Environment

The harelip sucker, Lagochila lacera, has not been seen since 1893
Image from Plate XXXVIII (Lagochila lacera) in Jordan and Evermann (1896a)

The invasive sea lamprey has had devastating consequences on native fish populations in the Great Lakes
Image from Black Lake Association

Lampreys are an invasive species in many areas feeding on native fish species
Image from Invasive.org

Coyote Peterson tests whether invasive lampreys will attack people.
Image from Eaten Alive on YouTube

Lamprey Exterminator episode of Dirty Jobs with Mike Rowe
Image from Discovery Go

bottom of page